Base44 vs Lovable: where your data lives, and what each leaves you to check

Base44 and Lovable both let the browser read the database directly, so access rules are the only lock in each. Lovable stores data in PostgreSQL on Supabase's open-source foundation, behind row level security. Base44 stores it in managed entities, where an operation with no rule stays open to everyone. Both ship a scanner that reads rules and code. Neither tells you what your published app answers a stranger.

The team behind Keybrum's attacksUpdated 11 min read

In short

  • Lovable keeps data in PostgreSQL with row level security policies. Base44 keeps it in managed entities with row-level and field-level rules. In both, the browser talks to the data directly.
  • A missing rule behaves differently: a Lovable table with RLS on and no policy returns nothing to the public key, while a Base44 operation with no rule stays open to everyone.
  • Lovable's Quick scan runs on every publish and its Deep scan reads the code on demand. Base44's scan is on every plan and warns at publish without blocking.
  • Both vendors hold SOC 2 Type II and ISO 27001, and both say in their docs that your app's rules are your responsibility.
  • The same test works on either: open the published app signed out, then as a second account, and see what comes back.
On this page

Base44 vs Lovable: the short answer

Both tools build a working app from a chat, and both host it for you. Seen from the security side, they are closer than their marketing suggests. In each one, the browser reads and writes your data directly, and a set of access rules is the only thing between a visitor and your records. The differences are in where the data sits, what happens when a rule is missing, and which checks each vendor gives you.

This page does not rank them on features or price. It compares them on one question: what must you check before real users arrive? Everything below comes from each vendor's documentation as of 13 November 2026. For each platform alone, see the Lovable security guide and the Base44 security guide.

Where each one puts your data

Lovable stores data in PostgreSQL. Its built-in backend is enabled by default and, in Lovable's words, uses Supabase's open-source foundation: a database, sign-in, file storage, realtime and edge functions. You can connect your own Supabase project instead. The browser holds a project address and a publishable key, which Lovable's docs call safe to be public, and talks to the database with them.

Base44, owned by Wix, stores data in entities: tables described by a JSON Schema and managed by Base44. There is no Postgres for you to open and no SQL editor. The browser talks to Base44's backend through its SDK, with the app's id and the visitor's session. Custom server logic goes into backend functions that run on Deno.

LovableBase44
DatabasePostgreSQL, in the built-in backend (on Supabase's open-source foundation) or your own Supabase projectManaged entities defined in JSON Schema, on Base44's own backend
How the browser reaches dataDirectly, with a publishable key that maps to the anon or authenticated roleDirectly, through the Base44 SDK with the app id and the visitor's session
What decides who reads a rowRow level security (RLS) policies, written in SQLRow-level and field-level rules on each entity
When a rule is missingRLS on with no policy: nothing is returned to the publishable key. RLS off: any role with a grant reads and writes the tableAn operation with no rule stays open to everyone, per Base44's reference
Server codeEdge functions; server code in apps created from May 13, 2026 (TanStack Start)Backend functions on Deno, each with its own HTTP address
SecretsEncrypted Secrets, injected into edge functions and server code, never sent to the browserEncrypted vault, readable only from backend functions with secrets.get()
Data regionAmericas, Europe or Asia Pacific, fixed once the backend is enabledEU, UK, Australia or US with data residency controls on Business or Enterprise
Certifications the vendor publishesSOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001:2022, AIUC-1. Not HIPAA compliant, no business associate agreementSOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001, GDPR with a data processing agreement on request
From each vendor's documentation, read on 13 November 2026.

A certification describes how the vendor runs its own company and platform. It says nothing about the rules inside your app. Both vendors write that down: Lovable says you are responsible for making sure your app meets the security requirements of its use case, and Base44 says you are responsible for your app's security settings.

What each protects by default

The most useful difference is what happens when nobody wrote a rule.

On Lovable's stack, the lock is RLS. Supabase's documentation says that once RLS is enabled on a table, no data is accessible through the API with a publishable key until you create policies. A table with RLS off is the opposite: readable and writable by any role that holds a grant on it. Lovable says it sets up rules automatically when it builds features that store user data. So the usual Lovable leak is a table where RLS is off, or a policy that is too wide, such as one whose condition is simply true.

On Base44, the reference for entity rules states that an operation with no rule stays open to everyone. Each of create, read, update and delete needs its own rule. When update and delete have no rule, they inherit the write rule, then the read rule. Base44 softens this in practice: when its AI creates a table, it adds permission rules in the same step and tells you which tables it covered, and it asks for approval before changing rules you already have. The usual Base44 leak is a table set to All Users on an operation that should have been Creator Only.

Server code follows the same split. A Lovable edge function or server route that uses an admin key skips RLS. A Base44 backend function that uses asServiceRole reads and writes without entity rules applying, and a function called by plain HTTP has no signed-in user at all. In both cases the function has to check its caller itself.

The security tools each one gives you

Both vendors ship real tools here, and both deserve credit for it.

LovableBase44
Built-in scanQuick scan: database rules, known npm vulnerabilities, MCP servers exposed without authentication. Runs automatically on every publishSecurity scan on all plans, the free plan included: permissions, user field access, private fields, exposed secrets, backend functions, credit protection, dependencies, security headers
Code reviewDeep scan: all application code across seven areas, from access control to exposed personal data. Starts only when you ask, or on a schedule for EnterpriseStatic code analysis inside the scan, on the Builder plan and above
Does it stop a publish?Optional workspace setting blocks publishing with critical findings, on by default for new Enterprise workspaces. Otherwise a review dialog, and you can publish anywayNo. The publish panel shows a Security status. It warns you and does not stop you publishing
Third-party static analysisWiz, connected at workspace levelWiz, with your own tenant, on the Builder plan and above
Test of the running appAikido AI pentest, billed by AikidoTenzai AI pentest on the published app since October 27, 2026, Builder plan and above, billed by Tenzai

Two limits apply to both. The built-in scans read your rules and your code. Lovable says so directly: its scanners and Wiz perform static analysis, and these tools cannot guarantee complete security. And a scan reports what the rules say at the moment it ran. A feature added the next day has not been looked at.

Base44's scan includes a check for user fields your rules rely on that users can edit, added on October 19, 2026, and one for private fields on records anyone can read. Lovable's Deep scan reads all your application code when you start it, while Base44 keeps static code analysis for the Builder plan and above. Neither fact decides which app leaks. The rules you ship do.

What is the same on both

Whichever you pick, the leak is in the deployed app. Three things are identical:

  • The rules on the data are the only lock. No server of yours sits between the browser and the database. On Lovable the public evidence is CVE-2025-48757: 170 of 1,645 Lovable apps scanned in March 2025 had missing or weak RLS, about one in ten. On Base44, Wiz Research reported in July 2025 a platform flaw that let anyone register on a private app, fixed by Wix within 24 hours. Its write-up notes that an app's id is visible in the address and was never a secret.
  • Anything in the bundle is public. The publishable key and the app id are meant to be there. A Stripe secret key, an OpenAI key or a service role key is a breach on either platform. See API keys exposed in the frontend.
  • Access is per user, and only you know your users. No scanner knows that a clinic's bookings are private and a restaurant's menu is public. A second account that opens the first account's record is an IDOR, and it looks the same on both stacks.

A self-check that works on either

Run these on your own app only. They take about twenty minutes and change nothing.

  1. 1

    Run the vendor's scan, the deep one

    Lovable: open the Security view and start the Deep scan, since the Quick scan does not read your code. Base44: Dashboard, Security, Run Security Scan. Read every finding before you accept a fix.

  2. 2

    Read the rules table by table

    Lovable: More → Database, Manage, then Policies. Look for policies that apply to anon and for policies that never mention auth.uid(). Base44: Dashboard, the table under Data, then Permissions. Write down who is allowed for each of create, read, update and delete.

  3. 3

    Open the published app signed out

    Use a private window with the developer tools on the Network tab. Browse every page and read what the data requests return. Records in those answers are records anyone gets.

  4. 4

    Ask the backend directly, with no session

    Send one request from a terminal, as in the block below. On Lovable, ask a private table for one row with only the publishable key. On Base44, call one of your backend functions with no cookie and no Authorization header.

  5. 5

    Repeat as a second account

    Sign up a fresh account and try to open a record that belongs to your first one, for example by changing the id in the address bar. If it loads, the rule checks sign-in and forgets the owner.

  6. 6

    Search the JavaScript for secret keys

    Paste the app's JavaScript into the API key leak checker. It runs in your browser and tells public keys from secret ones.

bash
# Your own app only.

# Lovable: one row of a private table, with only the publishable key
curl "YOUR_SUPABASE_URL/rest/v1/YOUR_TABLE?select=*&limit=1" \
  -H "apikey: YOUR_PUBLISHABLE_KEY"
# [] or an error: the table refuses strangers. A row: it does not.

# Base44: one backend function, with no session
curl -i -X POST "https://YOUR-APP.base44.app/functions/YOUR_FUNCTION" \
  -H "Content-Type: application/json" -d '{}'
# 401 or 403: the function checks its caller. 200 with data: it does not.
YOUR_SUPABASE_URL is the VITE_SUPABASE_URL value in your project's .env. Use a table you know holds rows: an empty answer from an empty table proves nothing.

What stays your job before real users arrive

  • Every table or entity that holds personal data limits read, update and delete to the record's owner
  • No rule relies only on the caller being signed in, and none trusts a field the user can edit
  • Every edge function or backend function rejects callers with no session, unless it is a webhook that verifies a signature
  • Functions that use an admin key or asServiceRole filter by the caller's id
  • No secret key in the JavaScript; all of them in Secrets, rotated if they ever shipped
  • AI and email features cannot be triggered by a stranger, see unprotected AI endpoints
  • The scan ran after the last change, and the published app was tested signed out and as a second account

The vibe coding security checklist extends this list, and the Supabase RLS guide has the policies for teams and shared records on the Lovable side.

What Keybrum tests on each, and what it does not

Keybrum is the automated pentest we build for apps made with AI. It attacks the published app from outside and keeps the request that worked as proof. Its coverage is not the same on the two platforms, and you should know the difference before you pay.

On a Lovable app, it reads the table names from your JavaScript, then tries to read, insert and update rows as a stranger and as a freshly signed-up account, and reads one account's rows from a second account. It calls your database functions, lists and uploads to storage buckets, subscribes to realtime channels, sends a short prompt to edge functions that look like AI endpoints, and looks for secret keys in the bundle and in rows anyone can read. Write tests use a marked record it creates itself.

On a Base44 app, it reads each entity named in your JavaScript with no session. That test is read-only and keeps counts, field names and one redacted record. It also searches the bundle for secret keys and checks security headers, exposed files and open AI endpoints. It does not test writes on entities today, and it does not read entities as a signed-in second account. Base44's own scan and the two-account test above cover that part.

On both, Keybrum does not review your code inside the builder, does not see your workspace settings, and only attacks apps whose owner proved ownership. A one-time report costs €49. Plans start at €29 a month excluding VAT for 5 apps and attack again on every deploy, which is when a rule changes.

Questions

Is Base44 or Lovable more secure?

Neither answer holds for every app. Both platforms are certified and both give you a scanner, and in both the rules on your data decide what a stranger reads. Compare them on what you will actually verify: the rules per table, the functions, the keys in the bundle.

Does Base44 use Supabase like Lovable?

No. Lovable's built-in backend uses Supabase's open-source foundation, with PostgreSQL and row level security policies. Base44 runs its own managed backend, where data lives in entities defined by a JSON Schema with row-level and field-level rules.

Where is my data stored on Lovable and on Base44?

On Lovable, in a PostgreSQL database in one of three regions (Americas, Europe or Asia Pacific), which cannot be changed once the backend is enabled. On Base44, in managed entities on Base44's backend, with a choice of EU, UK, Australia or US through data residency controls on Business or Enterprise. That also changes how you audit rules: SQL queries on Lovable, the Permissions page on Base44.

Do the built-in scans replace a penetration test?

No, and neither vendor claims so. Lovable describes its scanners as static analysis and suggests a professional review for apps with sensitive data. Both platforms offer an optional AI pentest from a partner, Aikido for Lovable and Tenzai for Base44, billed by that partner.

Which one is safer for health data?

Lovable states that it is not HIPAA compliant and does not sign business associate agreements. Base44's security overview does not mention HIPAA. If your app handles patient data in the United States, ask each vendor in writing before you build.

Sources

  1. 1.Security overview, Lovable Docs
  2. 2.Built-in backend, Lovable Docs
  3. 3.FAQ: tech stack and compliance, Lovable Docs
  4. 4.Secrets, Lovable Docs
  5. 5.Control who can access your app's data, Lovable Docs
  6. 6.Row Level Security, Supabase Docs
  7. 7.Base44 security: An overview, Base44 Docs
  8. 8.Base44 entities: Row-level security (RLS), Base44 Docs
  9. 9.Running a security scan, Base44 Docs
  10. 10.Managing data permissions, Base44 Docs
  11. 11.Backend Functions Overview, Base44 Docs
  12. 12.Product changelog, Base44 Docs
  13. 13.Critical Vulnerability in Base44, Wiz Research
  14. 14.Statement on CVE-2025-48757, Matt Palmer

Your app is public. So are its mistakes.

Check what any attacker can already see in it, free, in ten seconds. The full attack, with proof and fixes: €49 once, or €29 a month on a plan.

or continue with Google or GitHub